Hi Robert this is my first time here and I have been reading books and read your free reports. First I would like to congratulate you in taking time to assist us to improve our understanding of Feng Shui, etc.
I hope you can assist here :
Q1: I am a strong earth person (water in hidden stem) and require water and metal. Can I join in p'ship with another person who is a strong water person (with a number of water and metal)? Will both our strong elements complement one another and have a successful business ?
Q2: With penalties does one lose the elements like clashes ?
Thank you.

Dear Kean,
Please read below:-

Quote

On 1/10/00 10:04:36 PM, Anonymous wrote:
Hi Robert this is my first
time here and I have been
reading books and read your
free reports. First I would
like to congratulate you in
taking time to assist us to
improve our understanding of
Feng Shui, etc.
I hope you can assist here :
Q1: I am a strong earth person
(water in hidden stem) and
require water and metal. Can
I join in p'ship with another
person who is a strong water
person (with a number of water
and metal)? Will both our
strong elements complement one
another and have a successful
business ?

For the Strong Earth person, he will
benefit from the Strong Water person, as Water represents his wealth.
In addition, the Strong Water, will help to control the Fire preventing the further growth of Earth for the Strong Earth person.
The Strong Water person will benefit from the Strong Earth person in that Earth destroys Water thus, controlling the strong Water.
Generally, basing on that the compatibility seems to be pretty good.
As for whether it will result in a good careers, will have to depend on several other factors such as the Feng Shui of the Office, the type of business etc, and what period in their personal life do they want to venture into the business.
As many of the rest of the details are unknown or uncertain, I can say for sure.
But in the context of the two partnership, both will be able to benefit from each other's strength's and weakness.

Quote

Q2: With penalties does one
lose the elements like clashes
?
That depends on the clashes itself. There are many forms of clashes, good and bad, or clashes with good influence or clashes with bad influence.

Also, whether it is good or bad also depends on the whether the element is a favourable or unfavourable element to that person.
In addition, it also depends on what it is represented by.
Hope that helps.
Warmest Regards
Robert Lee

Quote

Thank you.